Differences Between Globe Valve and Gate Valve

Figure 1: Globe valve (left) and gate valve (right)

The company is a leading globe valve vs gate valve supplier, serving as your one-stop shop for all valve needs. Our specialized staff ensures that you find the right product for your application.

Globe and gate valves, while seemingly similar, have distinct differences making each suitable for specific applications. Knowing these differences can help select the correct valve considering the pressure, sealing, and flow requirements of the application. This article offers an in-depth comparison to equip you with the knowledge to choose between these two types of valves.

Table of Contents

Globe Valve vs Gate Valve: A Detailed Comparison

Both globe and gate valves are multi-turn, linear motion valves requiring multiple turns to open or close, moving the closure mechanism up and down to control flow. Beyond these basic similarities, their characteristics begin to diverge.

The globe valve is named after its rounded body rather than its disc, contrasting the gate valve. Its disc operates similarly to a gate, moving up and down to regulate flow. For a deeper understanding, you can read more on globe valves and gate valves.

Flow Characteristics

As depicted in Figure 2, a gate valve provides a straight-through, bi-directional flow arrangement, meaning it can handle flow in both directions with minimal resistance, except when closed.

Figure 2: Gate valve flow properties (closed on the left, open on the right).

In contrast, a globe valve has a more complex flow path, which could be a Z-shaped path (T- or Z-valve), an oblique path (Y-valve), or a 90° turn path (angle valve), as seen in Figure 3. The design inherently causes a significant pressure drop as the flow is diverted, unlike the near-zero pressure drop in gate valves.

Figure 3: Globe valve flow paths: T- or Z-valve (left), angle valve (center), and Y-valve (right)

Functional Roles

While both types can function as shut-off valves, their capabilities differ in flow regulation. Gate valves are not designed to throttle flow, whereas globe valves manage regulated flow efficiently, thanks to their design. However, globe valves are unsuitable for flow throttling in larger diameters (above DN 150). Both valves can be mechanically, pneumatically, or electrically operated.

Visual Identification

Identifying gate and globe valves can be challenging at a glance. However, here are distinguishing features:

• Body Shape: Gate valves have a rectangular or wedge-shaped body, while globe valves have rounder bodies, especially at the bottom.
• Height: Gate valves typically have greater height when fully opened compared to globe valves.
• Flow Direction Indicator: Gate valves are bi-directional, whereas globe valves include directional markers indicating unidirectional flow.

Advantages and Disadvantages

For more on the materials used in valves and their chemical resistance, refer to our guide. Below is an advantages and disadvantages chart of globe and gate valves:

Table 1: Globe valve and gate valve advantages and disadvantages chart

Choosing Between Globe and Gate Valves

Both gate and globe valves are excellent shut-off valves but excel in different applications. Key considerations include:

• Flow control: Opt for a globe valve for applications requiring flow modulation.
• Flow capacity: Select a gate valve for high-flow requirements.
• Flow direction: Choose a gate valve for bi-directional flow needs.
• Pressure drop: Prefer a gate valve if minimal pressure drop is crucial.
• Sealing: For enhanced sealing, select a globe valve.
• Contaminated media: Use a gate valve for slurry or contaminated media.

Refer to Table 1 for a more detailed comparison.

Typical Applications

Globe Valves

• Cooling Water Systems: Used to control water flow to maintain temperatures.
• Chemical Injection Systems: Ideal for controlling chemical injection in industrial setups.

Gate Valves

• Bulk Material Handling Systems: Suited for industries like mining, agriculture, and construction for controlling bulk material flow.
• Water Distribution Systems: Efficient for basic flow control without the need for precision.

FAQs

Which is better: a gate valve or a globe valve?

Globe valves offer better sealing and longevity, while gate valves provide a lower pressure drop.

What advantage do gate valves have over globe valves?

Gate valves require significantly less power to close, operating perpendicularly to the flow. Learn more at Customized Investment Castings Services.

Top ten Chinese valve brands
API 6D Gate Valve Selection - Slab vs Expanding

Both gate and globe valves are essential for controlling the flow of liquids and gases in industrial systems. While they appear similar, their functionalities are distinct. This article delves into these differences to help you decide the best valve for your needs.

Exploring Globe Valves

Named for their globe-like shape, globe valves belong to the linear motion valve family and are designed for starting, stopping, and regulating media flow. Most globe valves allow top-entry access. They provide an effective seal, making them suitable for high-pressure, high-temperature, and viscous media applications.

Due to their structure, they cause higher pressure drops and engage in better throttling. Despite being more expensive, their precision in flow control makes them a valuable choice in specific applications.

Understanding Gate Valves

Gate valves, part of the shutoff valve family, feature a wedge-shaped gate and an indicating stem. Their primary function is to isolate media, offering tight sealing without regulating flow. They can handle any flow direction and are ideal for applications requiring tight sealing, including those involving viscous media like in knife valves.

Key Differences: Globe vs. Gate Valves

Despite their similarities, globe and gate valves differ in functionality, structure, sealing, and application:

• Performance: Globe valves start, stop, and regulate media, while gate valves primarily isolate it.
• Structure: Globe valves have intricate internal components for flow adjustment; gate valves have simpler structures with top-located components.
• Sealing: Globe valves offer better sealing due to their internal valve core; gate valves seal only at the disc surface.
• Applications: Globe valves handle pressure-insensitive applications well; gate valves suit multidirectional flows needing minimal pressure drops.

Valve Solutions at RED-WHITE VALVE CORP.

At RED-WHITE VALVE CORP., we provide high-quality solutions for optimal system performance. With over 50 years of experience in commercial, industrial, HVAC, and plumbing industries, we can help you find the right valves for your applications. For more information on our globe and gate valves, Cencho Ball Valve.